Writing worksheet · Paragraph writing and editing

Paragraph Peer Review

A partner feedback form: a checklist for a strong paragraph, two stars, a wish and the writer’s plan.

Share:
Grade level
Grades 3–5
Time
About 25 minutes
Answer key
Not needed: answers vary
Kids practice
Paragraph structure, Topic and concluding sentences, Revising and editing, Proofreading

What kids do

“Trade paragraphs with a partner. Read it twice. Check what it has, then give two stars and a wish.”

Printed on the sheet:

  1. The paragraph has…
  2. Star 1 Something that works
  3. Star 2 Another thing I liked
  4. A wish One thing to try next
  5. Writer: what will you change after this review?

Teacher tip

Model kind, specific feedback first: “I like how you…” and “You could add…”

How to use it

  • Have kids use one color for revision and another for editing.
  • Post the editing or revision checklist on the board.
  • Read the directions aloud so the sheet is about writing, not decoding the directions.

Watch for

Revising and editing mixed up. Revising is the ideas; editing is the rules.

Talk about it

  • Which change made the biggest difference?
  • Where else do writers use this skill?

Take it further

Trade paragraphs with a partner for a peer edit.

US Letter, prints well in black and white. Free for home and classroom use: print as many copies as you need.

More paragraph writing and editing worksheets

See all 200 writing worksheets

Share this with a friend or teacher

Free for teachers

Get the free Classroom Drawing Kit

12 printable pages: six step-by-step lessons, a grid activity, draw-and-write sheets and teacher notes, sent with your welcome email. After that, new classroom printables by email.

Keep creating with Kevin

New book announcements and free drawing and coloring activity pages, delivered by newsletter.